Pelosi Sued by House Republicans for Defying Constitution with Mail-In Vote Push
Lawmakers sue speaker for defying ‘231-year constitutional tradition’ with proxy votin
Democratic House Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) is being sued by House Republicans for defying the U.S. Constitution by pushing proxy voting to usher in nationwide vote-by-mail.
The lawsuit against Speaker Pelosi was filed by House Minority Leader Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) on Tuesday evening.
The move is an attempt to block the House of Representatives from allowing lawmakers to vote on behalf of up to ten other members of Congress as a designated proxy voter.
Almost two dozen Republican members of Congress have signed on as plaintiffs in the lawsuit, in addition to McCarthy.
Among the names listed as defendants are the sergeant-at-arms and House clerk, two figures who serve a notable role in the proxy voting plan.
“I just filed a lawsuit in federal court to overturn Speaker Pelosi’s unconstitutional proxy voting scheme,” McCarthy tweeted on Tuesday evening.
“It could allow as few as 20 Representatives to control the votes of 220," McCarthy added.
"This is NOT the representative democracy our Founders envisioned or what our Constitution allows.”
I just filed a lawsuit in federal court to overturn Speaker Pelosi’s unconstitutional proxy voting scheme.— Kevin McCarthy (@GOPLeader) May 26, 2020
It could allow as few as 20 Representatives to control the votes of 220. This is NOT the representative democracy our Founders envisioned or what our Constitution allows.
Proxy voting would allow House members to vote on another person's behalf if they are not able to be physically present at the Capitol, an unprecedented exception for an unparalleled health crisis.
At least 59 Democrats have submitted letters to the House Clerk's office to authorize their vote to be cast by proxy, according to Fox News.
Meanwhile, GOP lawmakers have said they will be in the Capitol to cast their votes.
Not a single Republican supported the measure as it passed earlier this month, arguing that the Constitution requires a quorum, or a majority, of lawmakers to be physically present in order to vote on measures, thus concluding that the proxy system is unconstitutional.
Republicans also worry that the system concentrates too much power in the hands of only a few members.
McCarthy called the new voting rules "a dereliction of our duty as elected officials," and argued that "a small number of members dictating the businesses of the whole House while the people’s voice is diluted" would be a dangerous precedent to set.
McCarthy is at the helm of the lawsuit filed in the U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C., with the support of 20 other members of his party -- including Rep. Chip Roy from Texas, House Minority Whip Steve Scalise of Louisiana and GOP Conference Chairwoman Liz Cheney from Wyoming, as well as four constituents.
"It's simple: one representative should equal one vote. We can't let her get away with this," Scalise tweeted Tuesday
Pelosi called the lawsuit a "sad stunt" intended to "delay and obstruct urgently-needed action to meet the needs of American workers and families during the coronavirus crisis."
The speaker also argued that past rulings by the Supreme Court have upheld that the Constitution allows each chamber of Congress to set its own procedural rules.
For proxy voting, the House sergeant-at-arms and the attending physician have to notify lawmakers 24 hours in advance of invoking remote voting and the rule will stand for up to 45 days once it has been invoked.
“As our nation approaches the heartbreaking milestone of 100,000 lives lost to COVID-19, House Republicans must stop their dangerous obstruction and join Democrats to save lives, defeat the virus and grow the economy,” Pelosi said in a statement Tuesday.
"The rule change to allow remote voting in order to maintain public health fits within those bounds," House Majority Leader Steny Hoyer said.
"We should not endanger public health when technology can enable us to meet remotely – just as Senate committees, the Supreme Court, and businesses and schools across the country have done over the past few weeks."
The new voting system will likely take place as early as this week, and Republicans heading the lawsuit say they doubt the lawsuit will do anything to stop the votes from proceeding.